The Best Blenders For Protein Shakes: An In-Depth Guide And Review

The Best Blenders For Protein Shakes: An In-Depth Guide And Review

Protein shakes and smoothies are an efficient way of adding more protein to your diet. But to get the best tasting shake you need to use the correct equipment.

Picking the best blender for protein shakes and smoothies will depend on the shakes you want to make. If you want to blend pre and post workouts with only protein powder, you will be fine with just a normal protein shaker bottle.

But if you want to make protein shakes with oats, ice, bananas or other ingredients you’ll have to buy something that is capable of doing this.

Best Blender For Protein Shakes Comparison: 

A Quick Guide Before Buying Your Protein Shake Blender

You can pretty much use any quality blender for your protein shakes, but with so many options available how do you choose the best blender for your needs?

Start by familirising yourself with the different types available. The 3 main types you can use for protein shakes are:

  • Personal Blenders

  • Countertop Blenders

  • Hand Blender

Personal or bullet blenders are great for single serve shakes. They normally come with a to go cup and lid, which means you can make your shake and drink it on the go. They are also the easiest to clean and wont take a lot of space in your kitchen.

Countertop blenders are the big boys. They will crush ice, tough food like oats and spinach. If you plan on making protein shakes with a wide variety of ingredients you will want to go with a countertop blender. Countertop blenders are by far the best blenders for protein shakes with ice.

Hand or immersion blenders are your cheapest option. It is the perfect blender for people on a budget or planning on making simple protein shakes and smoothies.

Best Blender For Protein Shakes And Protein Smoothies

The Best Personal Blenders For Protein Shakes

Personal blenders are a popular and smart choice for protein shakes and smoothies. It’s a clean and simple blender to use. The blender cup is used to blend the shake or smoothie and then used to drink from.

It’s clean, simple and easy to use.

When Should Consider A Personal Blender For Protein Shakes?

If you’re going to add oats and bananas (or similar ingredients) to your protein shakes and want a blender that’s easy to use, small and compact and have a single serve cup.

Magic Bullet Nutribullet RX


  • 1700 watt gives you a thoroughly blended protein shake
  • Optimum nutrient extraction technology
  • Hands-free pre-programmed control


  • It is a bit pricey
  • The gasket is giving some people problems

The Magic Bullet Nutribullet RX is a compact and powerful blender. It’s the best personal blender for protein shakes if you’re willing to spend a little more.

The 1700 watt motor is more than enough to give you thorough blending of protein powders, oats and peanut butter (the most popular choice for protein shakes and smoothies).

The Nutribullet RX is designed for optimum nutrient extraction as its core focus. The SMART technology combined with the 1700 watt motor and turbo extractor blades pulverizes food to make the nutrients easier and faster to absorb.

This is exactly what you want from a post workout protein shake.

The advanced pre-programmed control makes it a completely hands-free process. It is programmed in such a clever way that it rotates at the correct speed, for the right amount of time at exactly the right intervals.

There is, however, a slight design flaw. The rubber gasket that seals the unit to prevent leaking is giving users some problems. Some users have complained of the gaskets completely disintegrating. For some, the gasket just never seals, which means it keeps on leaking.

Nutri Ninja Auto iQ


  • 1000 watt motor gives thoroughly blended shakes and smoothies
  • Auto IQ makes it an easy to use blender
  • The extractor blades are efficient and delivers great results


  • The locking mechanism fails on some units
  • The gasket is giving some people problems

The Nutri Ninja Auto IQ is pretty much on par with the Magic Bullet Nutribullet RX. It retails for just under $100.

The only real difference between the Nutri Ninja Auto IQ and Magic Bullet Nutribullet RX is the power of the motor.

The Nutri Ninja Auto IQ is powered by a 1000 watt motor. Still more than enough power to give you well blended protein shakes and smoothies.

Nutri Ninja Pro Extractor Blades is designed to pulverize whole fruits, ice, seeds, oats and vegetables.

It has an Auto IQ system which is similar to the Nutribullet RX. You only need to press one button to start the blending. It is programmed to do the rest.

The Nutri Ninja Cups makes it easy enjoy your protein shakes anywhere. It comes with a sip and a seal lid which means you can carry it in your gym bag.

It’s efficient and clean to use. You don’t need to blend your protein shake in one cup and pour it into another. You can do everyting with once cup.

The locking mechanism seems to be of a lower quality. There are a few users who have had it failing on them after only a couple of months. When this happens the blending cup can’t stay in position and it slides out of position. When it slides out of position the blender won’t work.

Magic Bullet Blender


  • 600-watt motor is good enough for simple protein shakes and smoothies
  • It’s the cheapest of the bullet blenders
  • It’s simple to use and easy to clean


  • Cheaper quality
  • Some people have the seal fail on them

The Magic Bullet is the cheaper version of the RX. It is still an excellent choice, especially if you’re on a tighter budget. It’s the best personal blender for protein shakes and smoothies on a budget.

The 600-watt motor is capable of blending and mixing protein powders to a smooth texture. But it struggles with frozen fruit and seeds. The more expensive personal blenders are much better at blending harder ingredients.

It is designed to be fast and simple. There are no on or off buttons. All you need to do to start blending is to load the cups and press downwards. It’s perfect for people that are looking for simple protein shakes that do not have a lot of ingredients.

The cheaper Magic Bullet does come with some quality issues. It’s not good at blending ice, frozen fruit and seeds as the other two units. There are also a few quality issues like the internals seizing and seals leaking.

But for the lower price, it is to be expected that it won’t be at the same quality level as the other two personal blenders.

The Best Blenders For Protein Shakes With Ice

You will need a blender with a bit more power if you want to use ice in your protein shakes and smoothies. There are hundreds of blenders on the market that’s great at crushing ice, but the 3 in this article are the ones that are the best for protein shakes.

The blenders recommended in the reviews below are effective in crushing ice and comes with the accessories you would need for protein shakes or smoothies.

So if you pick any one of the 3 Best Blenders for protein shakes with ice below you’ll be buying a blender that is worth your money.

BlendWorks Industrial Strength Professiona Blender


  • 1500 watt works fast and effectively
  • It will blend any ingredient
  • It is made from stainless steel


  • It is new to the market and faults are yet to surface

This is a blender with some serious blending power. If you plan on using your blender for more than just protein shakes this is the one to get.

It comes with a 20oz travel cup which makes it nice and simple to take your protein shakes with you.

The 6 way stainless steel blade is driven by a 1500 watt motor. It delivers on performance and pulverizes ice, frozen fruit, vegetables and other tougher ingredients like seeds with ease.

And if you are making tougher or thicker shakes with peanut butter you have the tamper that allows you the press and tamper from the top, to help with the blending.

This is a serious blender for people that are looking for a blender that will be capable of making protein shakes for meal replacements, post and pre workout with ice.

It will deliver smooth shakes and smoothies every time.

If you’re looking for a Vitamix or Blendtec quality but not able to afford it, this is your best option. It is the best blender for protein shakes with ice.

Jamba Appliances Quiet Shield Blender


  • 1200 watt motor blends ice easy
  • Quiet shield works well
  • Drive mechanism is made from steel. The blender should last a long time


  • If you don’t follow the instructions, you can end up with powder that’s not blended

The Jamba Quiet Shield blender is a great blender. The 1200 watt motor gives it more than enough power to blend and pulverize ice, tough food, and vegetables.

Most powerful blenders that are capable of dealing with ice are loud. This is where the Jamba excels. It comes with a quiet shield which makes it one of the quietest blenders on the market.

The interchangeable 20oz single serve travel cup and 32oz jug gives you the flexibility to make one or two protein shakes at a time.

The drive mechanism is made from steel, which makes it durable and strong. It’s a blender that should last a long time.

This is a great blender overall and especially for protein shakes. It blends, mixes and pulverizes very well.

If you use the 20oz single serve cup and do not follow the instructions on the order in which ingredients need to go in, there is a chance that some of the ingredients won’t get mixed. This happens mostly with powders and peanut butter.

This means if you’re going to buy it for protein shakes, make sure to follow the instructions.

Ninja Professional Blender with Single Serve (BL740)


  • 1100 watt motor delivers smooth protein shakes
  • It’s a very fast blender
  • The total crushing technology is effective in crushing ice


  • Plastic components wears out quickly
  • It’s loud

This Ninja Professional is the cheapest of the best blenders for protein shakes with ice. It is driven by a motor of 1100 watt that that is capable of blending and crushing most ingredients you’ll be using for protein shakes.

It comes with total crushing technology, which allows the Ninja Professional Blender to deliver professional blending power. With this technology, the blades can pulverize and crush through ice, fruit, and vegetables.

The blender is extremely fast and effective. Perfect for busy people on their way to the gym or for your post workout protein shakes.

The Ninja Professional is backed by advanced nutrient & vitamin extraction that provides a better tasting and more nutritious shake or smoothie full of vitamins and fiber.

It comes with two 16oz single serve cups with to go lids. The cups can be used on the base unit to turn it into a single serve.

One thing to be aware of, most of the components are made from plastic and some users have complained that it wears out quite quickly.

The Best Hand Blenders For Protein Shakes

If you’re just looking for a blender to help you achieve a nice smoothie pre or post protein shakes, a hand blender is a good option.

Don’t expect to be blending nuts, ice, and oats into smooth smoothies with a hand blender. The motors will usually be under 300 watt.

When Should Consider A Hand Blender For Protein Shakes?

It’s a good option if you’re going to make simple protein shakes. Peanut butter, bananas, and protein powder are blended quite easy with a hand blender.

Braun MQ505


  • Variable speed and turbo boost gives control for great results
  • 350 watt motor
  • Blends protein shakes well


  • It’s heavy

The Braun is backed by a Powerbell system that is designed to blend faster and better. The PowerBell system allows it to blend food in a flash with splashing and reduces suction.

It has a 2 speed variable speed control and a boost button which gives you the control to blend protein shakes into your desired consistency.

It has a 350 watt motor which is strong for a hand bender. You will be able to blend protein shakes into nice consistencies.

It is a sturdy blender and easy to maintain and clean up.

The bigger motor means it’s a bit heavier than other blenders. Something to consider, but it’s not a deal breaker.

Hamilton Beach 225 Watt Hand Blender


  • Variable speed and turbo boost gives you flexibility
  • Does a great job in blending protein powder
  • It is made from stainless steel


  • There is no switch so you have to keep pressing the button to blend

Hamilton is a well-known and respected brand. They make quality products and this hand blender is no exception. The Hamilton Beach Hand Blender comes with 225-watt blending power.

It has variable speed control and a turbo boost for tougher ingredients like peanut butter. The stainless steel blending wand feels like quality and it is made to last.

The blender jug is 24oz which is big enough to blend protein shakes with a few ingredients like milk, banana, and peanut butter. It does a great job in blending protein powder.

If you’re looking for a hand blender to make simple protein shakes this is a great choice.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the best blender for protein shakes will come down to your preference and needs.

So to help you pick the best one below is three questions you can answer which should help you buy the best one for your needs:

  1. What ingredients do you plan on blending?

  2. What will the normal serving size be?

  3. What is the amount of money that you are willing to spend on a blender? 

Answering these questions and using our buying guide will ensure you buy the best protein blender. If you need more help go to our in depth article on the best blenders currently available. 

Get Started With One Of The High Protein Smoothies Below:

High Protein Smoothie Recipes
Review Date
Reviewed Item
Best Blender For Protein Shakes
Author Rating

Leave a Comment